A role prompt sets a perspective, purpose or communication style. “Act as an editor” can focus a review, but the instruction does not supply professional credentials, personal experience or evidence. Define what the reviewer should inspect.
Turn a role into observable criteria
Compare “You are an expert editor; improve this” with “Review this invitation for an unclear date, missing booking details and unsupported promises.” The second request tells you how to judge the answer. You can keep the editor role as a shorthand, while using explicit criteria to control the task.
Anthropic’s prompting guidance describes roles as a way to focus behavior and tone. A role description is an instruction to the model, not a biography of the person answering.
Example: review an invitation
Approved brief: the workshop is Saturday at 10:00 in Room 4; participants bring a laptop; booking is required; the booking link is pending. Candidate: “Join our award-winning workshop this weekend. Everything is provided and places are guaranteed.”
Review the candidate as an invitation editor.
Use only the approved brief below.
For each problem, quote the candidate phrase, explain the mismatch,
and propose replacement wording. Then write a corrected invitation.
Brief: Saturday at 10:00, Room 4. Bring a laptop.
Booking required; booking link pending.
Candidate: Join our award-winning workshop this weekend.
Everything is provided and places are guaranteed.Example review
| Phrase | Problem | Correction |
|---|---|---|
| Award-winning | No award in the brief | Community workshop |
| This weekend | Omits the supplied day and time | Saturday at 10:00 |
| Everything is provided | Conflicts with the laptop requirement | Bring a laptop |
| Places are guaranteed | No capacity promise in the brief | Booking is required |
Example revision
Join the community workshop on Saturday at 10:00 in Room 4. Bring a laptop. Booking is required; the booking link is pending.
The value is in the quoted discrepancies and source-based corrections. A confident “expert” verdict without this evidence would be harder to inspect.
Compare with a role-free request
Remove the first sentence about being an editor and repeat the same criteria on a fresh candidate. Compare whether each review finds the factual mismatches, preserves the approved details and avoids adding promises. Record the differences you actually observe rather than assuming the role improves accuracy.
For specialist factual questions, supply the relevant primary material and evaluate the claims against it. Requesting the voice of a doctor, lawyer or investor does not create the qualifications those professions require. Practice tracing a claim to its source before relying on an authoritative-sounding answer.