A clear prompting goal names one deliverable and the conditions it must meet. Replace “make this good” with criteria another person can inspect: what the answer includes, what it excludes and where its facts come from.
Turn an intention into an acceptance check
For a workshop announcement, the goal is not “create engaging content.” It is “write an invitation that gives first-time attendees the confirmed logistics.” The evidence is the organizer’s brief. A useful acceptance check is whether the output preserves those logistics without adding promises.
OpenAI’s evaluation guidance recommends tests tied to the actual task. For this small writing task, a source comparison and a length check are more informative than an overall “quality” score.
Example: define three criteria
Approved facts: Saturday at 10:00, Room 4, bring a laptop. Booking is required and its link is pending.
- Include every confirmed logistical fact.
- Keep the booking link pending and add no unsupported benefits.
- Return one invitation under 60 words.
Write one workshop invitation under 60 words.
Facts: Saturday at 10:00, Room 4, bring a laptop.
Booking required; booking link pending.
Include all supplied logistics. Add no benefits or promises.
Keep the missing link pending.Example candidate that fails
Join our free workshop this weekend. Equipment is provided and you can arrive without booking.
It meets the length limit but fails both factual criteria. “Free” has no support; “equipment is provided” contradicts the laptop requirement; “without booking” contradicts the brief. A format pass is not a factual pass.
Example bounded correction
Correct the candidate using the supplied facts.
Remove the unsupported price claim, restore Saturday at 10:00
and Room 4, require a laptop and preserve the booking requirement.
Keep the link pending and the invitation under 60 words.Join the workshop on Saturday at 10:00 in Room 4. Bring a laptop. Booking is required; the booking link is pending.
Use criteria appropriate to the task
A schedule needs time and conflict checks. A summary needs support for each important claim. A creative scene needs the author’s chosen viewpoint and constraints. Define the important checks before generating an answer; otherwise a fluent response can quietly change what you meant to accomplish.
For practice, choose a different small deliverable and write three criteria. Ask someone to review an example against them. If they cannot decide what passes, make the criteria more concrete. Next, choose the context needed to meet those criteria.